Gas Town Mail Protocol

Reference for inter-agent mail communication in Gas Town

Overview

Gas Town agents coordinate via mail messages routed through the beads system. Mail uses type=message beads with routing handled by gt mail.

Message Types

POLECAT_DONE

Route: Polecat → Witness

Purpose: Signal work completion, trigger cleanup flow.

Subject format: POLECAT_DONE <polecat-name>

Body format:

Exit: MERGED|ESCALATED|DEFERRED
Issue: <issue-id>
MR: <mr-id>          # if exit=MERGED
Branch: <branch>

Trigger: gt done command generates this automatically.

Handler: Witness creates a cleanup wisp for the polecat.

MERGE_READY

Route: Witness → Refinery

Purpose: Signal a branch is ready for merge queue processing.

Subject format: MERGE_READY <polecat-name>

Body format:

Branch: <branch>
Issue: <issue-id>
Polecat: <polecat-name>
Verified: clean git state, issue closed

Trigger: Witness sends after verifying polecat work is complete.

Handler: Refinery adds to merge queue, processes when ready.

MERGED

Route: Refinery → Witness

Purpose: Confirm branch was merged successfully, safe to nuke polecat.

Subject format: MERGED <polecat-name>

Body format:

Branch: <branch>
Issue: <issue-id>
Polecat: <polecat-name>
Rig: <rig>
Target: <target-branch>
Merged-At: <timestamp>
Merge-Commit: <sha>

Trigger: Refinery sends after successful merge to main.

Handler: Witness completes cleanup wisp, nukes polecat worktree.

MERGE_FAILED

Route: Refinery → Witness

Purpose: Notify that merge attempt failed (tests, build, or other non-conflict error).

Subject format: MERGE_FAILED <polecat-name>

Body format:

Branch: <branch>
Issue: <issue-id>
Polecat: <polecat-name>
Rig: <rig>
Target: <target-branch>
Failed-At: <timestamp>
Failure-Type: <tests|build|push|other>
Error: <error-message>

Trigger: Refinery sends when merge fails for non-conflict reasons.

Handler: Witness notifies polecat, assigns work back for rework.

REWORK_REQUEST

Route: Refinery → Witness

Purpose: Request polecat to rebase branch due to merge conflicts.

Subject format: REWORK_REQUEST <polecat-name>

Body format:

Branch: <branch>
Issue: <issue-id>
Polecat: <polecat-name>
Rig: <rig>
Target: <target-branch>
Requested-At: <timestamp>
Conflict-Files: <file1>, <file2>, ...

Please rebase your changes onto <target-branch>:

  git fetch origin
  git rebase origin/<target-branch>
  # Resolve any conflicts
  git push -f

The Refinery will retry the merge after rebase is complete.

Trigger: Refinery sends when merge has conflicts with target branch.

Handler: Witness notifies polecat with rebase instructions.

RECOVERED_BEAD

Route: Witness → Deacon

Purpose: Notify Deacon that a dead polecat's abandoned work has been recovered and needs re-dispatch.

Subject format: RECOVERED_BEAD <bead-id>

Body format:

Recovered abandoned bead from dead polecat.

Bead: <bead-id>
Polecat: <rig>/<polecat-name>
Previous Status: <hooked|in_progress>

The bead has been reset to open with no assignee.
Please re-dispatch to an available polecat.

Trigger: Witness detects a zombie polecat with work still hooked/in_progress. The bead is reset to open status and this mail is sent for re-dispatch.

Handler: Deacon runs gt deacon redispatch <bead-id> which:

Rate-limits re-dispatches (5-minute cooldown per bead)
Tracks failure count (after 3 failures, escalates to Mayor)
Auto-detects target rig from bead prefix
Slings the bead to an available polecat via gt sling

RECOVERY_NEEDED

Route: Witness → Deacon

Purpose: Escalate a dirty polecat that has unpushed/uncommitted work needing manual recovery before cleanup.

Subject format: RECOVERY_NEEDED <rig>/<polecat-name>

Body format:

Polecat: <rig>/<polecat-name>
Cleanup Status: <has_uncommitted|has_stash|has_unpushed>
Branch: <branch>
Issue: <issue-id>
Detected: <timestamp>

Trigger: Witness detects zombie polecat with dirty git state.

Handler: Deacon coordinates recovery (push branch, save work) before authorizing cleanup. Only escalates to Mayor if Deacon cannot resolve.

HELP

Route: Any → escalation target (usually Mayor)

Purpose: Request intervention for stuck/blocked work.

Subject format: HELP: <brief-description>

Body format:

Agent: <agent-id>
Issue: <issue-id>       # if applicable
Problem: <description>
Tried: <what was attempted>

Trigger: Agent unable to proceed, needs external help.

Handler: Escalation target assesses and intervenes.

HANDOFF

Route: Agent → self (or successor)

Purpose: Session continuity across context limits/restarts.

Subject format: 🤝 HANDOFF: <brief-context>

Body format:

attached_molecule: <molecule-id>   # if work in progress
attached_at: <timestamp>

## Context
<freeform notes for successor>

## Status
<where things stand>

## Next
<what successor should do>

Trigger: gt handoff command, or manual send before session end.

Handler: Next session reads handoff, continues from context.

Format Conventions

Subject Line

Type prefix: Uppercase, identifies message type
Colon separator: After type for structured info
Brief context: Human-readable summary

Examples:

POLECAT_DONE nux
MERGE_READY greenplace/nux
HELP: Polecat stuck on test failures
🤝 HANDOFF: Schema work in progress

Body Structure

Key-value pairs: For structured data (one per line)
Blank line: Separates structured data from freeform content
Markdown sections: For freeform content (##, lists, code blocks)

Addresses

Format: <rig>/<role> or <rig>/<type>/<name>

Examples:

greenplace/witness       # Witness for greenplace rig
beads/refinery           # Refinery for beads rig
greenplace/polecats/nux  # Specific polecat
mayor/                # Town-level Mayor
deacon/               # Town-level Deacon

Protocol Flows

Polecat Completion Flow

Polecat                    Witness                    Refinery
   │                          │                          │
   │ POLECAT_DONE             │                          │
   │─────────────────────────>│                          │
   │                          │                          │
   │                    (verify clean)                   │
   │                          │                          │
   │                          │ MERGE_READY              │
   │                          │─────────────────────────>│
   │                          │                          │
   │                          │                    (merge attempt)
   │                          │                          │
   │                          │ MERGED (success)         │
   │                          │<─────────────────────────│
   │                          │                          │
   │                    (nuke polecat)                   │
   │                          │                          │

Merge Failure Flow

                           Witness                    Refinery
                              │                          │
                              │                    (merge fails)
                              │                          │
                              │ MERGE_FAILED             │
   ┌──────────────────────────│<─────────────────────────│
   │                          │                          │
   │ (failure notification)   │                          │
   │<─────────────────────────│                          │
   │                          │                          │
Polecat (rework needed)

Rebase Required Flow

                           Witness                    Refinery
                              │                          │
                              │                    (conflict detected)
                              │                          │
                              │ REWORK_REQUEST           │
   ┌──────────────────────────│<─────────────────────────│
   │                          │                          │
   │ (rebase instructions)    │                          │
   │<─────────────────────────│                          │
   │                          │                          │
Polecat                       │                          │
   │                          │                          │
   │ (rebases, gt done)       │                          │
   │─────────────────────────>│ MERGE_READY              │
   │                          │─────────────────────────>│
   │                          │                    (retry merge)

Abandoned Work Recovery Flow

Dead Polecat               Witness                    Deacon
     │                        │                          │
     │ (session dies)         │                          │
     │                        │                          │
     │                  (detects zombie)                 │
     │                  (bead status=hooked)             │
     │                        │                          │
     │                  resetAbandonedBead()             │
     │                  bd update --status=open          │
     │                        │                          │
     │                        │ RECOVERED_BEAD           │
     │                        │─────────────────────────>│
     │                        │                          │
     │                        │                    gt deacon redispatch
     │                        │                    gt sling <bead> <rig>
     │                        │                          │
     │                        │                          ├──> New Polecat
     │                        │                          │    (re-dispatched)

Second-Order Monitoring

Witness-1 ──┐
            │ (check agent bead last_activity)
Witness-2 ──┼────────────────> Deacon agent bead
            │
Witness-N ──┘
                                 │
                          (if stale >5min)
                                 │
            ─────────────────────┘
            ALERT to Mayor (mail only on failure)

Communication Hygiene: Mail vs Nudge

Agents overuse mail for routine communication, generating permanent beads and Dolt commits for messages that should be ephemeral. Every gt mail send creates a wisp bead in Dolt -- a permanent record with its own commit in the git-like history. This is a critical pollution source.

The Two Channels

gt nudge (ephemeral, preferred for routine comms)

Sends a message directly to an agent's tmux session
No beads created. No Dolt commits. Zero storage cost.
Message appears as a <system-reminder> in the agent's context
Suitable for: health checks, status requests, simple instructions, "wake up" signals
Limitation: if the target session is dead, the nudge is lost

gt mail send (persistent, for structured protocol messages only)

Creates a bead (wisp) in the Dolt database
Generates at least one Dolt commit (the write)
Persists across session restarts -- survives agent death
Suitable for: HANDOFF context, MERGE_READY/MERGED protocol, escalations, HELP requests, anything that MUST survive session death

The Rule

Default to gt nudge. Only use gt mail send when the message MUST survive the recipient's session death.

The litmus test: "If the recipient's session dies and restarts, do they need this message?" If yes -> mail. If no -> nudge.

Role-Specific Guidance

Role	Mail Budget	When to Mail	When to Nudge
Polecat	0-1 per session	HELP/ESCALATE only (gt escalate preferred)	Everything else
Witness	Protocol msgs only	MERGE_READY, RECOVERED_BEAD, RECOVERY_NEEDED, escalations to Mayor	Polecat health checks, status pings, nudge-and-observe
Refinery	Protocol msgs only	MERGED, MERGE_FAILED, REWORK_REQUEST	Status updates to Witness
Deacon	Escalations only	Escalations to Mayor, HANDOFF to self	TIMER callbacks, HEALTH_CHECK, lifecycle pokes
Dogs	Zero	Never (results go to event beads or logs)	Report completion to Deacon via nudge
Mayor	Strategic only	Cross-rig coordination, HANDOFF to self	Instructions to Deacon/Witness

Why This Matters (The Commit Graph)

Dolt is git under the hood. Every mail creates a Dolt commit. Over a day of normal operations:

4 agents x 15 patrol cycles x 2 mails per cycle = 120 commits just for routine chatter
These commits live in the git history forever, even after mail rows are deleted
Rebase can remove them, but prevention is always cheaper than cleanup

Anti-Patterns

DOG_DONE as mail -- Dogs should not mail their completion status. Use gt nudge deacon/ "DOG_DONE: plugin-name success" instead.

Duplicate escalations -- Witnesses sending 2+ mails about the same issue minutes apart. Check inbox before sending: if you already sent about this topic, don't send again.

HANDOFF for routine cycles -- Patrol agents (Witness, Deacon) doing routine handoffs should use minimal mail. If there's nothing extraordinary, just cycle -- the next session discovers state from beads, not from mail.

Health check responses via mail -- When Deacon sends a health check nudge, do NOT respond with mail. The Deacon tracks health via session status, not mail responses.

Implementation

Sending Mail

# Basic send
gt mail send <addr> -s "Subject" -m "Body"

# With structured body
gt mail send greenplace/witness -s "MERGE_READY nux" -m "Branch: feature-xyz
Issue: gp-abc
Polecat: nux
Verified: clean"

Receiving Mail

# Check inbox
gt mail inbox

# Read specific message
gt mail read <msg-id>

# Mark as read
gt mail ack <msg-id>

In Patrol Formulas

Formulas should:

Check inbox at start of each cycle
Parse subject prefix to route handling
Extract structured data from body
Take appropriate action
Mark mail as read after processing

Extensibility

New message types follow the pattern:

Define subject prefix (TYPE: or TYPE_SUBTYPE)
Document body format (key-value pairs + freeform)
Specify route (sender → receiver)
Implement handlers in relevant patrol formulas

The protocol is intentionally simple - structured enough for parsing, flexible enough for human debugging.

Beads-Native Messaging

Beyond direct agent-to-agent mail, the messaging system supports three bead-backed primitives for group and broadcast communication. All use the hq- prefix (town-level entities that span rigs).

Groups (`gt:group`)

Named collections of addresses for mail distribution. Sending to a group delivers to all members.

Bead ID format: hq-group-<name>

Member types: direct addresses (gastown/crew/max), wildcard patterns (*/witness, gastown/crew/*), special patterns (@town, @crew, @witnesses), or nested group names.

Queues (`gt:queue`)

Work queues where each message goes to exactly one claimant (unlike groups).

Bead ID format: hq-q-<name> (town-level) or gt-q-<name> (rig-level)

Fields: status (active/paused/closed), max_concurrency, processing_order (fifo/priority), plus count fields (available, processing, completed, failed).

Channels (`gt:channel`)

Pub/sub broadcast streams with configurable message retention.

Bead ID format: hq-channel-<name>

Fields: subscribers, status (active/closed), retention_count, retention_hours.

Group and Channel CLI Commands

# Groups
gt mail group list
gt mail group show <name>
gt mail group create <name> [members...]
gt mail group add <name> <member>
gt mail group remove <name> <member>
gt mail group delete <name>

# Channels
gt mail channel list
gt mail channel show <name>
gt mail channel create <name> [--retain-count=N] [--retain-hours=N]
gt mail channel delete <name>

Sending to Groups, Queues, and Channels

gt mail send my-group -s "Subject" -m "Body"           # group (expands to members)
gt mail send queue:my-queue -s "Work item" -m "Details" # queue (single claimant)
gt mail send channel:alerts -s "Alert" -m "Content"     # channel (broadcast)

Address Resolution Order

When sending mail, addresses are resolved in this order:

Explicit prefix -- group:, queue:, or channel: uses that type directly
Contains / -- Treat as agent address or pattern (direct delivery)
Starts with @ -- Special pattern (@town, @crew, etc.) or group
Name lookup -- Search group -> queue -> channel by name

If a name matches multiple types, the resolver returns an error requiring an explicit prefix.

Retention Policy

Channels support count-based (--retain-count=N) and time-based (--retain-hours=N) retention. Retention is enforced on-write (after posting) and on-patrol (Deacon runs PruneAllChannels() with a 10% buffer to avoid thrashing).

docs/agent-as-bead.md - Agent identity and slots
.beads/formulas/mol-witness-patrol.formula.toml - Witness handling
internal/mail/ - Mail routing implementation
internal/protocol/ - Protocol handlers for Witness-Refinery communication

Overview​

Message Types​

POLECAT_DONE​

MERGE_READY​

MERGED​

MERGE_FAILED​

REWORK_REQUEST​

RECOVERED_BEAD​

RECOVERY_NEEDED​

HELP​

HANDOFF​

Format Conventions​

Subject Line​

Body Structure​

Addresses​

Protocol Flows​

Polecat Completion Flow​

Merge Failure Flow​

Rebase Required Flow​

Abandoned Work Recovery Flow​

Second-Order Monitoring​

Communication Hygiene: Mail vs Nudge​

The Two Channels​

The Rule​

Role-Specific Guidance​

Why This Matters (The Commit Graph)​

Anti-Patterns​

Implementation​

Sending Mail​

Receiving Mail​

In Patrol Formulas​

Extensibility​

Beads-Native Messaging​

Groups (gt:group)​

Queues (gt:queue)​

Channels (gt:channel)​

Group and Channel CLI Commands​

Sending to Groups, Queues, and Channels​

Address Resolution Order​

Retention Policy​

Related Documents​

Overview

Message Types

POLECAT_DONE

MERGE_READY

MERGED

MERGE_FAILED

REWORK_REQUEST

RECOVERED_BEAD

RECOVERY_NEEDED

HELP

HANDOFF

Format Conventions

Subject Line

Body Structure

Addresses

Protocol Flows

Polecat Completion Flow

Merge Failure Flow

Rebase Required Flow

Abandoned Work Recovery Flow

Second-Order Monitoring

Communication Hygiene: Mail vs Nudge

The Two Channels

The Rule

Role-Specific Guidance

Why This Matters (The Commit Graph)

Anti-Patterns

Implementation

Sending Mail

Receiving Mail

In Patrol Formulas

Extensibility

Beads-Native Messaging

Groups (`gt:group`)

Queues (`gt:queue`)

Channels (`gt:channel`)

Group and Channel CLI Commands

Sending to Groups, Queues, and Channels

Address Resolution Order

Retention Policy

Related Documents